Abandoning an Author

When, if ever, do you abandon a favorite author? If you do, why do you abandon them?

I’ve done it many times. I’ve stopped reading the works of authors whose work I never expected to stop loving.

For as long as I can remember, I’ve loved books, writers, and reading. Over the years, I’ve had many favorite writers

My Favorite Reading Glasses


When I was a horse-crazy girl, I adored Walter Farley’s Black Stallion and Island Stallion books. I wanted to be a female Walter Farley when I grew up. I thought I would always love his work. Eventually, I outgrew his books and went on to other writers. A few years ago, I discovered that Farley hadn’t stopped writing when I’d stopped reading. I thought I’d enjoy catching up and reading the stories I’d missed. How disappointing to discover that Farley’s writing no longer held my interest.

As a teenager, I loved Emilie Loring’s books and read one after another. It soon became apparent that she’d been writing the same story over and over. Only the characters’ names and the settings were different. There was no reason to keep on reading.

More recently, I’ve enjoyed Patricia Cornwell’s books. I probably read at least fifteen of them. Even before I stopped reading her works, my pleasure in them was starting to pall. Her books became increasingly gory. Cornwell’s protagonist, Kay Scarpetta, is a medical examiner, who investigates crime scenes and performs autopsies, so of course, gore is to be expected. It seemed to me that in later stories the descriptions of crime scenes, the crimes themselves, and the autopsies became gratuitously gruesome as if the grisly details, and not the solving of the crime, were the point. What finally put an end to my reading of Cornwell’s mysteries was when she made a secondary character, Al Marino, behave in an ugly, criminal, totally out of character way. From the very first book, I never liked the way Cornwell treated Marino. He’s a seasoned police detective who regularly worked with Kay. He was supposed to be a good cop and a good guy, but the author treated him with contempt. She made him a fat, crude, semi-literate slob. His saving graces were his skill as a detective and his devotion to Scarpetta, who always outshone him. I’d already been thinking about giving up on these novels, but when there were no new books by my favorite authors available, I went back to Cornwell’s mysteries. The last straw for me was when she turned Marino into a rapist. No more Scarpetta. No more Cornwell.

There are still plenty of authors whose work I enjoy more. However, several of these writers now hang in the balance. Will I, or won’t I, read their most recent book? Writers get old and so does their writing.

There’s Nothing Like a Book and Coffee.

J.A. Jance is one writer whose books I will most likely no longer automatically read just because she wrote them. I’ve faithfully read her J.P. “Beau” Beaumont, Ali Reynolds, Joanna Brady, and Walker Family series. Seattle police detective Beaumont was always my favorite. Was. After the last Beaumont mystery I read, I have major doubts. Jance rehashes the plot of an earlier book and does not improve on it. She also turns Beau into a doggie-daddy. There are too many dog-walks interrupting the flow of the plot. Too much dog poop. Not enough material to interest me. I even have doubts about her other series.

John Grisham is another long-time favorite. My cousin and I both loved his books and have fun discussing them. Grisham has had interesting well-developed characters, pertinent details, and complex, intriguing plots, with surprising twists. Until recently, he kept his details under control. In his most recent books, the details have become bloated, the plots have grown flimsy and the endings have become lame. My cousin read one of Grisham’s latest tomes and said it was, “nothing.” I trust that my cousin is right.

I’m sad that these reliable writers are no longer so reliable. If I read their novels again, it will be their older ones. Thank goodness new writers are always coming along. Thank goodness for libraries which allow me to sample these new discoveries without buying before I’m sure their works are worth the money. Thank goodness for older writers whose books remain to be discovered.

John Work Garrett Library. Baltimore, Maryland. Wouldn’t This be a Fabulous Library to Explore?

6 thoughts on “Abandoning an Author”

  1. I have stopped reading Andre Brink because he died on a plane somewhere over South Africa. I love his books and someday will finish all of them. He is a wrier who changed my life and I want him back from God.


    1. That’s not the sense in which I meant abandoning an author, Peggy. You still love Brink’s books. And he apparently died without through a decline.. I abandoned the authors I mentioned because they no longer write good books. They write tedious, rambling stuff with no plot and their prose has turned turgid. Their egos get in the way. Apparently no one edits their books because readers keep buying the books because of the famous name. So why bother editing?


  2. Thanks, Judy! I’m glad you found my provocative and that you liked the photos. I think you’re right that it is inevitable that as we grow and mature, experience more of the world our tastes are bound to change. It seems that famous authors are not subject to editing in the same way less well-known authors are, to the detriment of both author and reader. They also seem to get lax in self-editing–also a detriment.


  3. Provocative post, great photos. I’ve moved on from many old favorites. Over time my tastes change, or the tastes of the authors I follow change, or both. It’s natural, maybe even inevitable. But we’ve had our moments of intersection, and that is enough.


  4. Interesting, although it makes me sad that you have lost interest in so many authors. The more I read many of the newer authors, the more i revert to the “tried and true,” whose books line my keeper shelves. I find comfort in these difficult, housebound times from visiting old friends who live inside the covers and do not require social distancing.


    1. I’m glad you found my post interesting, Colleen. Don’t feel sad that I’ve abandoned these, and other, authors. I’ve grown and changed and so have my tastes. There are still many writers whose work I will always enjoy and will gladly read again. Many fine new writers are out there, that I’m not going to waste my time reading works that I have to slog through, wondering when the book will end. It seems I will have to write a post about authors I will never abandon.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s